Skip to main content

Bill Nye Speaks Out

SEE:  http://www.wptv.com/dpp/news/world/bill-nye-creationism-video-the-science-guy-goes-viral-warns-of-creationisms-effect-on-mankind


I must say, I am impressed with the statistics in this article, if not so much with the video...I see this as both helpful and harmful to people of different belief groups...He predicts the end of Creationism--I am not so certain that is going to happen...Thoughts?

Comments

James said…
I'm not so sure that "the denial of evolution is unique to the United States." I seem to recall that my son Todd encountered fundamentalists in China who did so. I'm betting some of the Christian groups I met in Zambia did likewise, and I know that during Darwin's own day there were Irish Christians who disagreed. I see nothing helpful for Christian groups in denial. Ultimately, I think it's symptomatic of an anti-intellectualism that is very destructive. And I think Nye is right that Creationism will not survive--not if Galileo is an appropriate model. On the other hand, literalism as an hermeneutic is still going strong, not just in Christianity. This suggests the possibility that Nye's prediction will not come true.
I think Xtians "deny" evolution because of the apparent conflict with Genesis...and because total adherence to evolution as a concept is in conflict with God's sovereignty [e.g., no need for God with evolution]...I do not think that will change...one can be willing to wait for the answers to these conflicts [God will explain all one day] so there is no need to ignore evidence [from one's spiritual experience or from science] and also no need to just "accept as fact" something one does not believe in...Why not entertain ALL sources of evidence and wait for enough to be able to make a solid decision?
Mr Nye is actually saying something kind of inflammatory--"if you teach your children of your idea of creationism you will hurt them and society." I don't think that is true.
Colleen said…
I agree with with you, Jim, that anti-intellectualism is rampant - it must be if, as the linked article claims, 46% of Americans today believe in Creationism apart from evolution in any form. When one goes to such an extreme as to call in to question scientific findings that have been corroborated over many decades as lies, and insists that God cannot be sophisticated enough to use these mechanisms to achieve the processes so elegantly distilled (for B.C. minds) in the chapter of Genesis, this is indeed anti-intellectualism. I also agree with Wayne that some Christians, rather than actually doubting science, feel pressure to eschew it in order to be a good believer. This destructive climate within the Church will not, unfortunately, just go away, I think; there is (and rightly so, to some degree) an attitude of "we must be very cautious how much modern thought we allow to influence our teachings." If we could have dialogues, among fellow believers and among the population in general, in which enlightenment and not debate is the order of the day, I think we could make progress.

Popular posts from this blog

The Tao of Pooh

Wayne, I like what you said about uncertainty. The way I see it, the less we know about a proposition, the more staunchly we tend to defend it. It happens in science too much. But it happens in religion, even more. In the end, we can know with some certainty what we feel at the moment. And with a great deal of reasoning we can be pretty sure of the proposition "I think I think; therefore I think I am." Further afield, we actually know very little. So I tend to think that the truth of a religious proposition lies not in some essence of fact, but in how we would feel about living in a group, a society, a world that embraces the same proposition. For example "all people are equal before the law." When religious ideas and practices help us to be more kind, reflective, and open to other people, I think they can help us feel better about our place in society. And they can help us be part of a happier society. It is my opinion, however, that a great deal of theolog...